Read the document before the number
A rating belongs to an identified shield and configuration. Before comparing numbers, match the unit, layout, issuer and revision to the applicable design record. [3] [2]
Tabulated data are tables and charts approved by a registered professional engineer and used to design and construct a protective system. A sales listing does not establish that basis. Pro-Tec’s Pro Series literature directs the reader to the manufacturer’s serialized specific tabulated data before each use; its jobsite photos are general product information. [1] [3]
Match the shield and its spreader layout
Record the basic identifying features before judging applicability: manufacturer, model designation, serial number, panel style and wall construction, internal spreader arrangement, height, length, the revision or issue date on the certification sheet, and the engineer whose approval the document identifies. A catalogue table supplies these only row by row. Model, height by length, weight, pipe clearance and rating columns describe a configuration, not the specific steel box in your trench. [3] [2]
A family table shortlists candidate configurations; it does not govern the steel trench box in the trench. Under the federal standard, a trench box designed from manufacturer's tabulated data must follow the full set of that manufacturer's specifications, recommendations and limitations. Any deviation requires the manufacturer's specific written approval, and that written material must be at the jobsite while the protective system is built for that trench box. [2] [3]
Pro-Tec describes both four- and five-pipe layouts. On its engineer-stamped certification sheets it calls for at least two spreader pipes at each end with approved pins and keepers; it describes a fifth spreader as generally providing additional stiffness. These details explain why the internal layout matters for the Pro Series example. They are not a parts list for another shield. [3]
If the pins, keepers, pipe arrangement or other components differ from the matching sheet, record the discrepancy rather than carrying the rating across. Under the manufacturer-data route, deviating from specifications, recommendations or limitations requires the manufacturer’s specific written approval. [2] [3]
Read the Pro-Tec footnote beside the depth columns
Pro-Tec’s depth columns depend on pressure assumptions stated in a footnote. Shield capacity, an assumed pressure increase with depth and the actual site loading are three different quantities. [3] [2]
The Pro Series four-inch double-wall table separates “Shield Capacity” from “Depth of Cut.” Its footnote defines PSF (pounds per square foot) as maximum shield capacity. Its B, C-60 and C-80 depth columns use assumed pressures per foot of depth; the footnote directs the reader to determine actual soil pressure and consult the manufacturer’s tabulated data before each use. Those are Pro-Tec’s column labels and assumptions, not a classification of your ground. [3]
A depth calculated for an assumed pressure is not a universal safe depth. Without the applicable configuration and the actual loading, the table cannot establish the depth suitable for the proposed work. [3] [2]
Note which design route the project is on; different trench projects can follow different routes. The standard allows manufacturer's tabulated data; other tabulated data, which must identify parameters affecting selection, state limits of use, include explanatory information and name the approving engineer; or a design approved by a registered professional engineer with a written plan showing sizes, types and configurations. The engineer definition is keyed to registration in the state where the work is performed, with an interstate provision for approving designs for manufactured protective systems or tabulated data. Contractors should record the full route alongside the steel box identity. [2] [1]
Sources
- 29 CFR 1926.650: Scope, application, and definitions applicable to this subpartOccupational Safety and Health Administration
- 29 CFR 1926.652: Requirements for protective systemsOccupational Safety and Health Administration
- Pro-Tec Pro Series steel trench shields — selected document and spreader contextPro-Tec Equipment