Start with the shield that is on site
A model plate identifies equipment, but it does not show which loads or configurations the design permits. For a trench shield, match the unit and its assembled components to the written design and then compare its limits with the excavation conditions. [1] [2] [3]
Which written design applies?
Section 1926.652(c) covers support, shield and other protective systems. Three of its routes apply to shields: manufacturer tabulated data, other tabulated data, and a design approved by a registered professional engineer. Sloping and benching are covered separately in paragraph (b). [3]
Paragraph (c)(1) directs timber shoring to Appendices A and C and aluminum hydraulic shoring to manufacturer data or, when that data cannot be used, Appendix D. Those shoring tables do not cover a manufactured trench shield. [3]
On the manufacturer-data route, follow every specification, recommendation and limitation. A deviation requires the manufacturer’s specific written approval. [3]
Option 3 relies on other tabulated data, such as tables and charts. The written data must identify the parameters that affect selection of a protective system, identify the limits of use of the data, and include explanatory information needed to select correctly. The copy kept for the job must identify the registered professional engineer who approved that data. [3]
Option 4 is a design approved by a registered professional engineer, in written form, including a plan that indicates the sizes, types and configurations of materials to be used and the identity of the engineer approving it. The definition keys registration to the state where the work is to be performed, with a specific allowance for engineers registered in any state when approving designs for manufactured protective systems or tabulated data used in interstate commerce. [3] [1]
Matching the assembly to the record
Compare the model or series identifier and the installed components with the configuration shown in the governing document. A family name alone does not identify the assembly. [3]
Check the documented limits against the intended use and actual loading conditions. If the drawing or tables do not cover a proposed arrangement, a photograph or a catalogue label cannot supply the missing design basis. [3]
When the written copy must be at the jobsite
Two questions belong together in a records review: what must the copy contain, and where must it be available? On the manufacturer-data route, a file location without the manufacturer’s actual limitations and any specific written deviation approval does not answer the first question. [3]
For manufacturer data, other tabulated data and an engineer’s design, the required written material must be at the jobsite during construction of the protective system. Afterward it may be stored off site, but a copy must be available to the Secretary upon request. [3]
What the retained copy must show differs by route. The manufacturer's route requires the specifications, recommendations and limitations, plus any written approval to deviate. The other-tabulated-data route requires a copy that identifies the approving registered professional engineer. The engineer-design route requires the design itself, including the plan of sizes, types and configurations and the engineer's identity. [3]
Inspection and damage are separate from design
Even a complete design record does not describe conditions at the start of a shift. Where employee exposure can reasonably be anticipated, the competent person inspects the excavation, adjacent areas and protective systems before work, as needed throughout the shift, and after every rainstorm or other hazard-increasing occurrence. Remove exposed employees when conditions indicate a possible cave-in, system failure, hazardous atmosphere or other danger, until precautions are taken. [2]
Damaged equipment follows a different path. A competent person examines damaged material or equipment and evaluates its suitability for continued use. If that person cannot assure the item is able to support the intended loads or is otherwise suitable for safe use, it must be removed from service and evaluated and approved by a registered professional engineer before it returns. That approval step is conditional on the competent person's inability to assure suitability, not a routine annual formality. [3]
Water content, nearby backfill, equipment weight and traffic vibration can change the conditions on which a design comparison was based. Do not carry yesterday’s assessment forward after a hazard-increasing change. [4]
Sources
- 29 CFR 1926.650: Scope, application, and definitions applicable to this subpartOccupational Safety and Health Administration
- 29 CFR 1926.651: Specific excavation requirementsOccupational Safety and Health Administration
- 29 CFR 1926.652: Requirements for protective systemsOccupational Safety and Health Administration
- Preventing Worker Deaths from Trench Cave-ins (NIOSH Workplace Solutions 2011-208)CDC and NIOSH