Skip to content
Trench ShoringBoxes

Shoring guides

How to check a proposed trench protection design against the site

Compare the soil, depth, water and equipment on site with the assumptions in a proposed trench protection design. Learn when a change calls for another review.

Updated November 20, 20267 min read

What the Proposal Review Is Deciding

Start with the location where the proposed system will be used. Which soil, depth, water and load assumptions does its design depend on, and what evidence from that location supports them? [1] [3] [4]

Start by locating the design basis the proposal claims to follow. OSHA's excavation standard allows protective systems to be selected through specified options, including appendices, manufacturer tabulated data, other tabulated data, or a registered professional engineer's design. Each route has written documentation and limits. A proposal that cannot be tied to a route and revision is not ready for a yes-or-no disposition; it is ready for a documented question. [3] [1]

OSHA's general trench safety duty is a useful screen. Employees in excavations must be protected from cave-ins by an adequate protective system, except where the excavation is entirely in stable rock or is less than five feet deep and a competent person finds no indication of a potential cave-in. The review should record which exception, if any, is being relied on, rather than assuming a shallow trench is exempt. [3]

Matching the Proposal to the Documented Design Basis

At each location covered by the proposal, compare the planned depth, soil or rock, nearby loads and water conditions with the assumptions in the design. A soil description on a drawing is not a site observation. [3] [2]

Identify the design route before judging the hardware. Sloping and benching proposals may rely on the standard's allowable configurations, appendices, tabulated data, or an engineer's written design. Support, shield, and other protective systems follow a parallel set of options, including manufacturer data and engineer designs. The reviewer should check that the proposal uses the route it names and that the supporting document matches the actual configuration. [3] [1]

Method names are not interchangeable. A shield is intended to resist cave-in forces and protect employees inside it, while trench shoring supports the sides of an excavation to prevent cave-ins. A support system may also brace an adjacent structure or underground installation. If a proposal mixes shielding, shoring, sloping, or benching, the review should state what each element is expected to do and which document governs it. [1]

Checking Configuration Documents and Open Assumptions

A soil description on the proposal and a soil assumption in a table may use the same words without coming from the same evidence. Keep the field basis, the table’s stated scope and any proposed departure on separate lines so the reviewer can identify exactly which link is missing. [1] [3]

The diagram distinguishes evidence for conditions at the site, the identified configuration and assumptions in the manufacturer’s data, and specific written approval for a proposed deviation.Field basisWhat evidence supports the proposed soildescription?Table scopeWhich assembly and assumed conditions does itcover?Proposed departureWhich change requires specific writtenmanufacturer approval?
Three records behind a claim that a proposal falls within manufacturer data.

For a named manufactured system, contractors should ask for the written tabulated data, instructions, and limitations that apply to that model and site conditions. A family brochure or a page from a different revision is not enough to establish a limit of use. The reviewer should compare the proposed depth, system type, panels or rails, connection details, and soil assumptions against the available safety document rather than inferring limits from the product name. This applies to aluminum hydraulic shoring, trench shields and other trench shoring equipment, where the exact model and revision matter. [3]

Where the proposal draws on manufacturer's tabulated data, OSHA requires use within all specifications, recommendations, and limitations. A deviation is permitted only after the manufacturer issues specific written approval. That approval, along with the manufacturer's data, must be in written form at the jobsite during construction of the system. The review should record the document title, revision, and the exact condition the approval addresses, because this is a safety compliance point rather than a matter of preference. [3]

If water is present where the proposal assumed a dry trench, identify the affected part of the design. Do not treat an unverified soil description or an apparently similar component as a match. [3] [1]

Reviewing Interfaces with Adjacent Work, Utilities, Water and Access

Utilities are a design-basis interface, not a separate locating chore. Before excavation, the estimated location of underground installations must be determined; utility owners are contacted within local response times; and the exact location is established by safe means as work approaches. While the excavation is open, those installations must be protected, supported, or removed as needed. The review should ask whether the proposal accounts for each known or reasonably expected installation and its support. [2]

Adjacent structures and surfaces also belong in the comparison. Where excavation endangers the stability of adjoining buildings, walls, or other structures, shoring, bracing, or underpinning is required to protect workers. Excavation below the level of the base or footing of a foundation or retaining wall that could reasonably be expected to pose a hazard to employees is not permitted unless a support system such as underpinning is provided, the excavation is in stable rock, or a registered professional engineer approves a determination that the structure is sufficiently removed to be unaffected or that the work will not pose a hazard to employees. Sidewalks, pavements, and appurtenant structures must not be undermined unless a support system or another protective method is provided. [2]

Water, access and the type of mobile equipment can change the proposal's assumptions. Employees may not work in an excavation with accumulated or accumulating water unless adequate precautions are taken, and dewatering must be monitored by a competent person. Trenches four feet or more deep need a safe means of egress—such as a ladder, stairway or ramp—within twenty-five feet of lateral travel. Where mobile equipment operates near an edge and the operator lacks a clear view, a warning system is required. [2]

Loose material and surface encumbrances should be recorded as interface questions. Surface encumbrances that create a hazard must be removed or supported. Excavated material and equipment that could fall or roll from an excavation face or into the excavation must be kept at least two feet from the edge or restrained by retaining devices. The review should note which contractors are responsible for those controls, the safety risks they address, and why they may sit outside the protective-system supplier's scope. [2]

Separating Shielding From Soil Support

For a trench box, check movement, entry conditions and other safety conditions as well as the load limit. The box must not be subjected to loads beyond its design, must be installed to restrict lateral or other hazardous movement under sudden lateral loads, and must protect workers entering and exiting the protected area. Workers must not remain in a trench box while it is being installed, removed, or moved vertically. [3]

The bottom-of-shield condition is a common review point. Excavating no more than two feet below the bottom of a shield is permitted only if the shield is designed for the forces calculated for the full trench depth and there are no indications of possible soil loss from behind or below the shield. A proposal should show how that condition will be maintained, not merely state the shield's depth. [3]

For support systems, review the sequence as part of the proposal. Members must be securely connected, not loaded beyond design, and protected during temporary removal. Removal should begin at the bottom and proceed upward, with members released slowly and backfilling coordinated with removal. Excavation below the bottom of support members has a similar two-foot condition tied to full-depth design and no signs of soil loss. [3]

Checking Equipment Condition, Handling and Installation Assumptions

Equipment condition is part of the documented basis. Materials and equipment used in protective systems must be free from damage or defects that could impair their proper function and must be used and maintained consistently with the manufacturer's recommendations. When damage is found, a competent person must examine the equipment and evaluate whether it remains suitable. If the evaluation cannot assure that the equipment can carry the intended loads or is otherwise safe for workers, it must be removed from service. This is a basic safety check for trench boxes, trench shields and other trench shoring systems and equipment in the trench shoring industry, not a cosmetic inspection. [3]

If the competent person cannot assure that damaged equipment can support its intended loads or is otherwise suitable for continued use, remove it from service. A registered professional engineer must evaluate and approve it before it returns. [3]

Handling and installation assumptions should also be named. Support-system installation must be closely coordinated with excavation of the trench, and installation and removal must protect employees from cave-ins, structural collapse, and struck-by hazards from members. Shield movement creates its own exclusion condition. The proposal should identify who directs the sequence, what equipment is needed, and where work stops if a condition changes. [3]

When conditions change

Where employee exposure can reasonably be anticipated, a competent person inspects before work, as needed during the shift, and after rainstorms or other hazard-increasing events. If evidence of a hazardous condition is found, remove exposed employees until the necessary precautions are taken. [2] [3]

Sources

  1. 29 CFR 1926.650: Scope, application, and definitions applicable to this subpartOccupational Safety and Health Administration
  2. 29 CFR 1926.651: Specific excavation requirementsOccupational Safety and Health Administration
  3. 29 CFR 1926.652: Requirements for protective systemsOccupational Safety and Health Administration
  4. Preventing Worker Deaths from Trench Cave-ins (NIOSH Workplace Solutions 2011-208)CDC and NIOSH