Skip to content
Trench ShoringBoxes

Aluminum shoring

Aluminum Hydraulic Shoring and Aluminum Shields: Two Different Jobs in the Trench

Aluminum hydraulic shoring is built to support trench walls; a shield is built to withstand a cave-in. How the parts and the required design documents differ.

Updated November 20, 202610 min read

Aluminum Hydraulic Shoring as a Support System, Not a Shield

Two arrangements can arrive at the same trench and still do different jobs. Trench shoring systems support the walls and are designed to prevent cave-ins. A shield, by contrast, is built to withstand cave-in forces and protect the workers inside it. Aluminum describes a material, not a role; an aluminum hydraulic shoring arrangement is not a trench box. Which role an arrangement fills comes first, because OSHA's definitions treat shoring and shielding as separate protective systems. [1]

OSHA's excavation definitions describe aluminum hydraulic shoring as a pre-engineered shoring system. Aluminum hydraulic shoring systems use hydraulic cylinders, called crossbraces, with vertical rails (uprights) or horizontal rails (wales). The stated purpose is to support the sidewalls of an excavation and prevent cave-ins, an active soil-support role in which members bear against the wall face. [1]

Cylinders, Uprights, Wales and Sheeting: How the Parts Meet the Ground

“Across” and “along” are easy to reverse in a parts description. Read each member relative to the excavation face: the wale runs along it, the crossbrace spans across it and the upright stands vertically. The sketches show vocabulary, not a set of parts to install together. [1]

Upright, wale and crossbrace: which direction?Three isolated parts. The upright runs vertically; the wale runs along a face; the crossbrace runs across the opening. These are directions, not a parts list. Read each member by its directionThree vocabulary sketches, not one assembled system. UprightVertical at the faceWaleHorizontal along the faceCrossbraceHorizontal across the opening
Three directions in OSHA’s shoring vocabulary.

In aluminum hydraulic shoring, the standard's terms locate each member. Crossbraces are horizontal members set perpendicular to the trench sides, with their ends bearing on either uprights or wales. Uprights are vertical members touching the earth; they are usually spaced apart, and closely spaced or interconnected uprights are often called sheeting. Wales run horizontally parallel to the trench face and bear against the verticals or the earth. Where wales are used, crossbrace load can pass through them to the uprights or the earth. [1]

Those positions produce two common shoring systems in aluminum hydraulic shoring. One uses vertical hydraulic shores, where hydraulic cylinders push against uprights that contact the trench faces; these are often described as hydraulic shores. The other uses a horizontal waler shoring system, where wales run along the faces and the cylinders push against them, with sheeting used where the soil must be retained. Appendix D states that when a waler system is used, the vertical timber sheeting is selected from the same tables as the cylinders and wales, and shore spacing is part of that selection; the same shoring tables also govern wale and cylinder spacing. [1] [5]

The distinction identifies which member bears directly on the soil and whether sheeting is part of the arrangement. In trench shoring systems, OSHA defines kickout as the accidental release or failure of a cross brace, and its support provisions require members to be securely connected to prevent sliding, falling, kickouts, or other predictable failure. The required installation sequence for a hydraulic shore matters because workers may be inside the trench while the support is placed or removed, and the arrangement must protect them from cave-ins, structural collapses, or being struck by members. [1] [3]

Vertical Shores and Horizontal Waler Systems in Appendix D

Appendix D to Subpart P is titled Aluminum Hydraulic Shoring for Trenches. Its scope is limited to trenches no deeper than 20 ft, and the standard requires it when the design of an aluminum hydraulic protective arrangement cannot be performed under the tabulated data route in 1926.652(c)(2). Those conditions make the appendix a bounded fallback, not a general trench shoring specification or a substitute for project-specific shoring design. [5] [3]

Within that scope, the appendix separates hydraulic shoring systems by ground classification. It presents tables for vertical hydraulic shores in Type A and Type B soil, and separate tables for horizontal waler systems in Type B and Type C soil. The ground must be classified under Appendix A before any table is used. Vertical spacing is held constant at four feet on center; horizontal spacing of hydraulic shores or cylinders is selected from trench depth, width, hydraulic cylinder size and member size, and the tables give maximum spacings. For vertical hydraulic shores, the required minimum is three shores in each group, with equal horizontal spacing. A complete selection therefore needs the trench depth, width and classified ground type. [5]

The appendix also states its limits. Its tables cover situations common in trenching practice, not all trenching conditions or every trench width. Where a situation falls outside them, each hydraulic shore in the aluminum hydraulic shoring system for that trench must be designed under 1926.652(c). That is the clearest reason products should not be treated as interchangeable, and why equipment and hydraulic shoring selection belongs against a complete set of project documents, including required tabulated data, rather than a generic label, because workers rely on the installed arrangement and the risk of soil movement. Those hydraulic shores, their connections and the trench wall protection they provide need review as a shoring system. [5]

How a Shield's Job Changes the Comparison

The trench box provisions in 1926.652(g) show how different the complete review becomes. A box must not be subjected to loads beyond what it was designed to withstand, and its installation must restrict lateral or other hazardous movement if sudden lateral loads are applied. Workers must be protected from cave-ins while entering or exiting the protected area, and no one may remain inside while a box is installed, removed, or moved vertically. Those requirements concern the trench protection the box provides, not the hydraulic shore that may be used elsewhere in the same trench. They are required limits rather than suggestions, and treating them as optional changes the risk. [3]

Excavation up to two feet below a shield is permitted only if the shield is designed to resist the forces calculated for the full trench depth and there is no indication of possible soil loss from behind or below it while the trench is open. [3] [1]

A box's documentation answers a different set of questions: what forces the structure resists, at what depth, and how it may be handled and moved. The design routes remain separate. A table for hydraulic shoring does not establish a shield's capacity, and a shield's dimensions do not establish a shoring capacity. [3] [1]

Soil, Geometry and Loading Details to Check Against Design Information

A complete shoring review starts with the facts Appendix D uses: classified soil type, trench depth and width, cylinder size, member size, and whether vertical shores or wales are used. The proposed arrangement's horizontal and vertical spacing must not exceed the table's maximum spacings, and any sheeting requirement must be met. Appendix D measures spacing center to center and bases selection on the trench depth and width where the members will be installed; an entry used outside those conditions is not a table selection. [5]

Appendix D also names conditions under which its shoring table members are not adequate. One is a vertical load on a crossbrace above the appendix's stated threshold. Another is surcharge loading from equipment weight above its stated limit; where equipment weight passes that weight limit, the table entry no longer establishes adequacy. A third is shoring only the lower part of a trench while the upper part is sloped or benched, unless that slope is flatter than three horizontal to one vertical or the members are selected using a depth measured from the top of the overall trench. In any of those cases, an alternative hydraulic shoring system or other protective system must be designed under 1926.652, and the risk belongs in the review. A table entry chosen without checking those limits does not establish adequacy, and each hydraulic shore and the shores it bears against need that check. [5]

Those are limits on the tables, not conditions a crew can clear on its own. A protective system, including shoring, is required to resist, without failure, all loads that are intended or could reasonably be expected to be applied or transmitted to it. Individual members must not be subjected to loads beyond what they were designed to withstand. [3]

Site Conditions That Can Change the Review

Utility work and utility coordination add required steps to excavation planning. Before a trench is opened, the estimated location of utility installations must be determined, and the utility owner or utility company must be contacted within established or customary local response times before actual excavation starts. When excavation approaches the estimated location, the exact location of each utility line must be established by safe and acceptable means. While the excavation is open, the utility installation must be protected, supported, or removed as necessary to safeguard employees. [2]

Water and nearby structures are separate triggers. Employees may not work in an excavation with accumulated or accumulating water unless adequate precautions are taken, and where adjoining buildings, walls, or structures are endangered, support systems such as shoring, bracing, or underpinning must be provided. Loose rock and soil protection, plus keeping spoil and equipment at least 2 feet from the edge, belong in the same plan. [2]

Access, egress and inspection complete the site picture. A trench 4 ft or deeper needs a stairway, ladder, ramp or other safe means of egress requiring no more than 25 ft of lateral travel. A competent person inspects the excavation, adjacent areas and protective systems, including shoring, before work begins, as needed during the shift, and after every rainstorm or similar hazard increase, removing exposed workers when evidence of potential cave-ins appears. That inspection is a required safety routine for all workers inside the trench, not a one-time sign-off, because risk can change during the shift. [2]

NIOSH's 2011 Workplace Solutions document offers planning recommendations rather than regulatory text, and it is dated guidance. It advises designating a competent person, calling 811 before digging, evaluating soil conditions, planning spoil and equipment routes, and treating trenches deeper than 20 feet as more complex work that may call for a manufactured system with an appropriate depth rating or a registered professional engineer's site-specific design. [4]

Manufacturer Tabulated Data, Appendix D and the Design Route

OSHA's design options determine which required document should be on the jobsite. Under 1926.652(c)(2), a shoring arrangement drawn from manufacturer's tabulated data must follow all of the manufacturer's specifications, recommendations, and limitations. Any deviation requires the manufacturer's specific written approval, and the specifications plus any approval must be in written form at the jobsite while the equipment is being installed. A complete set of those documents belongs in the review, not as an optional extra. [3]

Other routes exist. Tabulated data from another source is required to identify selection parameters, state the limits of use, and include explanatory information. A copy identifying the approving registered professional engineer must be at the jobsite during construction of the protective system; afterward it may be stored off site but made available to the Secretary on request. Where no listed option applies, a registered professional engineer must approve the design. OSHA defines tabulated data as tables and charts approved by such an engineer. [3] [1]

Appendix D is the route that applies when manufacturer tabulated information cannot be used for aluminum hydraulic shoring within its scope. For applications outside its tables, and for trenches deeper than that scope, the appendix itself directs users back to the manufacturer's tabulated information or to other shoring design options, including hydraulic shoring systems. Asking which route applies to a single hydraulic shore, a group of hydraulic shores, or an aluminum hydraulic shoring arrangement, and why, is more informative than comparing equipment names for a project. [5] [3]

Document Requests for an Application Review

For a proposed hydraulic system, identify the model and arrangement, then ask which design data cover the soil, geometry and loads at this excavation. [3] [5]

For support materials, shoring components and equipment, 1926.652 sets required conditions: freedom from damage or defects that could impair proper function. A competent person is required to examine damaged items and evaluate suitability for continued use; if the person cannot assure they can support intended loads or are otherwise safe, they must be removed from service until a registered professional engineer evaluates and approves their return. Support members must be securely connected to prevent sliding, falling, kickouts, or other predictable failure, and removal must begin at the bottom of the excavation with backfilling progressing alongside it. [3]

Sources

  1. 29 CFR 1926.650: Scope, application, and definitions applicable to this subpartOccupational Safety and Health Administration
  2. 29 CFR 1926.651: Specific excavation requirementsOccupational Safety and Health Administration
  3. 29 CFR 1926.652: Requirements for protective systemsOccupational Safety and Health Administration
  4. Preventing Worker Deaths from Trench Cave-ins (NIOSH Workplace Solutions 2011-208)CDC and NIOSH
  5. 29 CFR 1926 Subpart P, Appendix D: Aluminum Hydraulic Shoring for TrenchesOccupational Safety and Health Administration